bonsai and persistentvolumeclaims

Question

Wondering if anyone has had success using bonsai with persistentvolumeclaim module configs in their project It looks like every one of ours is resulting in the error Could not find Build action <volume claim name> The goal here is to gradually migrate so ideally I won t need to convert all volume claim modules into actions in order to get past this error

bright-policeman-43626 · Answer

By any chance are you using this action and reusing it with the Deploy action https docs garden io kubernetes plugins action types persistentvolumeclaim

mammoth-kilobyte-41764 · Answer

Technically I am not using any actions directly I m trying to run all the existing modules I ve got as a first step So I ve got a persistentvolumeclaim type of module and then I ve got container modules that list the volume claim under their volumes key

bright-policeman-43626 · Answer

Oh I get it you are just trying to deploy with the new Binary keeping your old syntax with 0 12

mammoth-kilobyte-41764 · Answer

Well I ve made the breaking changes listed to move to version 1 of the syntax but I haven t converted any of my modules to actions yet

mammoth-kilobyte-41764 · Answer

My project specifies apiVersion garden io v1

bright-policeman-43626 · Answer

So right now what is failing is trying to use a `pvc` that was created previously with 0 12 and I guess you are trying to reference it in a container `Deploy` action

bright-policeman-43626 · Answer

oh no Any of your modules are actions yet

bright-policeman-43626 · Answer

So everything is the same from 0 12 but you changed all the deprecations breaking changes and trying to deploy with Bonsai fails with ` Could not find Build action <volume claim name> `

bright-policeman-43626 · Answer

How much of a hard lift would it be to share some example snippets with us to facilitate the debugging process < gardenheart 1083685896169209926>

mammoth-kilobyte-41764 · Answer

Definitely a tad more work than posting here in Discord but I wondered if this would be a new one for y all I ll try to reproduce this minimally and share the project config

mammoth-kilobyte-41764 · Answer

I m trying a couple more things first to see if this is related to me already having a 0 12 deploy up

mammoth-kilobyte-41764 · Answer

That gave me some interesting information I deleted my namespace in k8s and then did a `garden deploy force refresh` and although I got some of the same pvc errors I got about 1 10th as many as before

mammoth-kilobyte-41764 · Answer

Oh right because it wasn t able to resolve later modules with dependencies that hadn t deployed yet so it only errored out for the first wave of modules those with no dependencies

mammoth-kilobyte-41764 · Answer

Ok this reproduces the problem for me https gist github com mattpolzin a150decd458079786951c4c557be7082

bright-policeman-43626 · Answer

Thanks a lot I ll try to deploy this on my end and share with the team maybe < calm family 29323> you could take a look into this one once you start your day < frogplease 993594182134415560>

calm-family-29323 · Answer

yeah this looks just like a bug in our module >action conversion logic I ll be on it once I start my working day

mammoth-kilobyte-41764 · Answer

Thank you both

mammoth-kilobyte-41764 · Answer

Not that I d expect a rapid fix but should I keep an eye out here for updates in this or would you rather I create a GitHub issue that I can keep an eye on

bright-policeman-43626 · Answer

Hey sorry for taking so long on this one please feel free to create a Github Issue so we can prioritize it as this indeed looks like a bug Cc < swift garage 61180> looks like the conversion logic

calm-family-29323 · Answer

Sorry this took so long but the fix is in review via https github com garden io garden pull 4523 and will be soon available on the edge branch

mammoth-kilobyte-41764 · Answer

No worries I appreciate the follow up in this thread to let me know about the fix PR Thanks

mammoth-kilobyte-41764 · Answer

I ll mark this resolved unless y all want to wait for a release I ve confirmed the fix against my project

bright-policeman-43626 · Answer

Thanks a lot < mammoth kilobyte 41764> < calm family 29323> this is good to be resolved